Meaning of good safe port and berth in a modern shipping world
PhD ceremony: | Mr A. Kharchanka |
When: | February 27, 2014 |
Start: | 11:00 |
Supervisor: | prof. mr. dr. M.H. (Mathijs) ten Wolde |
Co-supervisor: | dr. M.J. davies |
Where: | Academy building RUG |
Faculty: | Law |
Sailing from one port to another in order to deliver goods is
one of the main purposes of any commercial maritime adventure.
Although most of the ports in the world have some kind of
navigational history and are described in detail on maps,
groundings, delays, and other accidents still occur to vessels.
With the growing complexity of vessels and the increasing cost of
their operation, the amount of damages that the ship owner can
suffer by delaying a vessel due to congestion or repairs can be
significant.
The issue of safe ports and berths naturally stems from the
vessel’s operation. This dissertation delineates a meaning of
safe ports and berth under English and American law, discusses a
standard of culpability of the parties, and sets benchmarks on
physical, political, administrative and ecological safety.
A standard of liability of the parties responsible for nomination
of the port is explained in detail. Under English law, it is a
warranty of the charterers that encompasses strict liability for
nomination of an unsafe port. American law provides two approaches:
one of a warranty given by the charterers; another of a duty of due
diligence of the charterers in selecting a port.
Physical, political, administrative and environmental conditions
of the port are discussed with examples of court’s decisions
and arbitration awards. The dissertation concludes with a proposal
that the due diligence approach will best reflect the modern
realities of the shipping world.