Sex roles in birds describe sex differences in courtship, mate competition, social pair-bonds, and parental care. Different explanations have been put forward to explain these differences but none are based on a comprehensive study. Therefore, an international team of experts set out to analyse data on 1,800 of the approximately 9,000 different species of birds as their study organisms. The results show that adult sex ratios are the main driving force for differences in sex roles. A paper on this study was published in Ecology Letters on 25 February.
In birds, there can be huge differences between the sexes, both in characteristics, such as size or colour, and in behaviour, such as courtship or parental care. ‘There are differences between bird species but there is also quite a bit of variation within species,’ says Jan Komdeur, Professor of Evolutionary Ecology at the University of Groningen. All this may affect how birds can adapt to changing circumstances, such as climate change, and cope with anthropogenic threats, such as habitat loss. It is therefore useful to know exactly how differences in sex roles have evolved.
A classic explanation is that of gametic investment: females produce just a few eggs each year but each rich with nutrients, while males have nearly unlimited supplies of tiny sperm in their semen. ‘The idea is that this makes females choosier,’ explains Komdeur. However, this alone is not enough to explain all sex role differences. Other contributing factors that have been proposed are climate, life histories, and social factors. ‘However, no comprehensive analysis has been performed of their effect across bird species.’
Back in 2014, Komdeur discussed this with his colleague Tamás Székely, Professor at the Milner Centre for Evolution in the UK, who spent several months at the University of Groningen as a visiting scholar funded by the Dutch Research Council NWO. ‘We got in touch with a postdoctoral researcher, Alejandro Gonzalez-Voyer, who was keen to undertake such an analysis.’ This task turned out to be of Herculean proportions: there are around 9,000 bird species and he had to collect data on sex roles and variables that might affect them for all of these.
The sex roles in this study were competition and attraction of mates, pair-bonding, and parental care. Sexual size dimorphism, sexual dichromatism, social mating system, and parental investment in post-mating care were used as proxies for these roles. Four drivers for differences in sex roles were analysed: the climate in which each species lives, life-history (such as the life span), social environment (especially the sex ratio in adult birds), and phylogeny (the ancestry of a species).
‘The job was more complex than we had anticipated,’ acknowledges Komdeur. ‘It could take up to a week to assess one species. Some 6,000 birds were investigated and, in the end, we obtained a full data set for 1,800 species. Only those were used in the analysis.’ The results showed that climate, life histories, and phylogeny had no significant effect on sex roles in birds. ‘This is surprising since the literature suggests that climate and life history are important; however, this was often based on studies with just a few species.’
The only factor that significantly influenced sex roles was the social environment, specifically the adult sex ratio. As predicted, males provide more parental care when the adult sex ratio became more male-biased. One explanation for this is that when there is a surplus of males, competition for a mate may become increasingly costly for them, thus males may benefit more from staying with the family and allocating more energy to care for the young. On the other hand, when there is a surplus of females, they do not have to spend a lot of energy on finding a mate and, therefore, can invest more in their young.
The scientists made sure that the statistical power of a comparison between 1,800 species was enough to detect significant contributions to sex roles. They also corrected for other possible confounders. Overall, the biologists found a lot of variation in sex roles within species. ‘It is very rare that sex roles are completely fixed in a species.’ The adult sex ratio is determined by a difference in mortality between the species and this may be driven by climate changes. These processes should be investigated in a new study. Komdeur: ‘We do not know everything but our study does show that the social environment is an important driver of sex roles.’
Reference: Alejandro Gonzalez-Voyer, Gavin H. Thomas, András Liker, Oliver Krüger, Jan Komdeur and Tamás Székely: Sex roles in birds: Phylogenetic analyses of the influence of climate, life histories and social environment. Ecology Letters, 25 February 2022
Prof. Moniek Tromp has been appointed Captain of Science of the Chemistry Top Sector by the Minister of Economic Affairs and Climate Policy. As from 1 July 2023, she succeeded Prof. Bert Weckhuysen from Utrecht University.
Leonardo Arriagada Beltran conducted his PhD research on the interface of computer-generated art and the constantly evolving field of Artificial Intelligence (AI). He will defend his Phd thesis on 21 September. His research offers valuable insights...
Harish Vedantham and Casper van der Kooi have been nominated by New Scientist for Wetenschapstalent 2023 (Science Talent 2023). This election is meant to give young scientists and their research a stage.
The UG website uses functional and anonymous analytics cookies. Please answer the question of whether you want to accept
or reject other cookies (such as tracking cookies).
If no choice is made, only basic cookies will be stored. More information