Skip to ContentSkip to Navigation
founded in 1614  -  top 100 university
Research Graduate School of Philosophy PhD ceremonies

Warm philosophy and the politics of science

A communicative critique of formal social epistemology of science
PhD ceremony:T.H. (Thijs) Ringelberg, MAWhen:November 10, 2026 Start:14:30Supervisors:prof. dr. J.W. (Jan-Willem) Romeijn, R. (Russell) Spears, ProfCo-supervisor:L. (Leah) Henderson, ProfWhere:Academy building UGFaculty:Philosophy
Warm philosophy and the politics of science

Warm Philosophy and the Politics of Science

How should we build theories about people in philosophy? This is the central question this dissertation wrestles with. The work consists of two interlocking parts. On the one hand, it develops an understanding of philosophy as a conversation in which everyone should be able to take part; on the other, it unfolds several critiques of formal social epistemology of science (FSEOS).

The understanding of philosophy as a conversation is built on the philosophy of Jürgen Habermas. The aim of the conversation is to make sense of what it is to be a human being in the world. Because all humans have the same tools for arriving at such self-understanding, all humans should in principle be able to join the conversation. The conditions of the philosophical conversation are therefore openness, kindness, and trust.

There is, however, a tendency within the philosophical conversation to merely explain others instead of listening to them, thereby excluding them from the conversation. This tendency is called philosophical coldness. FSEOS is an example of a cold discipline: it builds mathematical models of scientific communities with the aim of explaining and influencing the behaviour of scientists.

In the dissertation, the nature of coldness is investigated through analyses of the history, concepts and policy consequences of formal models of science such as those FSEOS produces. Finally, it argues that FSEOS should be “warmed up” by entering into a direct conversation with the scientists it speaks about.

View this page in: Nederlands