Skip to ContentSkip to Navigation
About us Latest news News News articles

Financial information leaflets offer too little protection for consumers

10 September 2018
Carien de Jager: Information does little to help

The information leaflets supplied with complex financial products fall short of the mark. People still run a substantial risk of losing money. This is the conclusion of Carien de Jager, after conducting research for which she will be awarded a PhD by the University of Groningen on 20 September. According to De Jager, financial information leaflets are inadequate for protecting consumers and the government overestimates them.

Complex financial products are combination products that involve investments, such as investment funds and life insurance contracts with an investment component. Many of them are unsuitable for consumers, and providing information does little to change this, says De Jager. She studied ten different Dutch, German, English and European information leaflets.

Information does little to help

The profiteering policies and securities lease affairs are prominent examples of situations in which many people lost money because of financial products that they didn’t understand. In an effort to protect consumers from situations like these, the government made information leaflets for financial products compulsory. For example, the Financial Information Document was introduced in the Netherlands in 2001, and replaced with the Key Information Document in 2018. De Jager tried to find out whether leaflets like these actually help consumers to understand the products and make better informed decisions, but she concluded that providing information about financial products does little to help.

Not rational decisions

De Jager does not believe that the leaflets are the right way to approach consumers. ‘This method doesn’t relate to what we currently know about consumers. A consumer is not a computer that can process information and automatically make a good decision. Consumers can be irrational and make mistakes. Providing information isn’t an appropriate way of dealing with this type of behaviour: one needs to be rational to understand information.’

Foto: Erik van 't Woud/Hollandse Hoogte
Foto: Erik van 't Woud/Hollandse Hoogte

Incomprehensible texts and unmotivated people

Many of the information leaflets are also incomprehensible, with too much technical jargon, long sentences and difficult words. According to De Jager, the information could be made easier to understand by using simple language and adding pictures to the text. But she is not convinced that better leaflets will necessarily help people to compare financial products, and she has serious doubts about the efficacy of these leaflets in general. ‘You can’t change consumers. For many people, information simply doesn’t play a role in their investment decisions. In addition, many consumers aren’t motivated to read about financial products, or don’t have the knowledge and skills to understand the products they are considering.’

Introduce extra measures rather than withdraw the leaflets

So, information leaflets are not the right instrument for helping people to understand and compare complex financial products. But should they be withdrawn? De Jager: ‘They can be beneficial. Unlike marketing material, they are an objective source of information. I wouldn’t recommend withdrawing them, but I do think that legislators overestimate them. We shouldn’t spend a disproportionate amount of money, time and effort on such a relatively ineffective instrument. We’ve been doing this at both a European and national level for over thirty years now, without much success. If we really want to protect consumers, we need to look further.’ However, De Jager doesn’t hold out much hope for alternative methods either. ‘An information document is an easy political tool. Alternative solutions that take things a step further, such as a ban on certain products, will meet with resistance from various parties.’

More information

Carien de Jager

The risk indicator of the Dutch 'Financiële Bijsluiter'
The risk indicator of the Dutch 'Financiële Bijsluiter'
Last modified:12 March 2020 9.23 p.m.
View this page in: Nederlands

More news

  • 12 January 2024

    Leon Verstappen awarded a royal decoration during anniversary conference

    Leon Verstappen (Meijel, 1965), Professor of Notary Law at the Faculty of Law of the University of Groningen, was surprised with a royal decoration in the category Officer of the Order of Orange-Nassau on Friday 12 January. During the anniversary...

  • 11 December 2023

    Join the 'Language and AI' community

    As a part of the Jantina Tammes School, the 'Language and AI' theme is an interdisciplinary initiative that aims to encourage collaboration among academics, PhD candidates, students, and industry representatives who share a keen interest in the...

  • 05 December 2023

    Clashing human rights: how far can demonstrators go?

    Blocking motorways, protesting against abortion, and waving torches outside a politician’s home. The right to demonstrate is of great importance, but sometimes causes friction with other human rights. For her PhD research, Noor Swart is looking...