Who’s the patient? Ethics in and around material-fetal surgery
PhD ceremony: Ms. M.L. Misarela Loureiro Rodrigues, 16.15 uur, Academiegebouw, Broerstraat 5, Groningen
Dissertation: Who’s the patient? Ethics in and around material-fetal surgery
Promotor(s): prof. P.P. van den Berg, prof. M. Düwell
Faculty: Medical Sciences
Maternal-Fetal surgery (MFS) consists of a series of surgical techniques which aim at correcting or improving the outcome of life-threatening or severely debilitating congenital birth defects, such as congenital diaphragmatic hernia and myelomeningocele. Today, most of MFS remains investigational, as its safety and efficacy are still to be proven. For some indications and for a small number of patients, MFS has however become the standard of care. In either case, although the fetus is the surgery’s immediate or potential beneficiary, in order to operate on it, surgeons must inevitably pass through the woman’s abdomen, uterus, and membranes, causing harms to her health that she would not endure were she to continue her pregnancy to term without MFS, were she to terminate that pregnancy, or were she to be pregnant with a ‘healthy’ fetus. This undeniable and apparently innocuous fact, is however the source of many “headaches” for pregnant women, physicians, moral philosophers, ethicists and lawyers. The different chapters of this thesis deal with some of the causes of those “headaches”, namely, 1) What is owed, morally, to those involved in MFS (women and fetuses)? 2) How should the ethical review of MFS research protocols (namely, randomized controlled trials (RCT)) proceed, on which basis, and according to which criteria should they be ethically sanctioned? 3) How much weight should be given to patient/research subject’s preferences in the design and conduct of MFS RCT? 4) Under which conditions can Dutch patients be referred for MFS for myelomeningocele? 5) How should the counseling of prospective candidates proceed?
Last modified: | 13 March 2020 01.00 a.m. |
More news
-
06 June 2025
India-Netherlands Hydrogen Valley Fellowship Programme announced
To coincide with World Environment Day, 5 June 2025, the Indian Department of Science and Technology and the University of Groningen yesterday announced a Hydrogen Valley Fellowship Programme Partnership, allowing talented Indian scholars working on...
-
28 May 2025
Gaan avondmensen cognitief sneller achteruit dan ochtendmensen?
Wie ’s avonds opleeft en laat naar bed gaat, heeft een grotere kans op cognitieve achteruitgang dan een ochtendmens, blijkt uit UMCG-onderzoek.
-
27 May 2025
An adventure in the brain
In the exhibition Brainstorm in the University Mueseum, Iris Sommer and two other brain researchers from Groningen explain the gut-brain connection, how it was discovered that the brain does what it does, and how games motivate you to perform...