Skip to ContentSkip to Navigation
About us Latest news News News articles

Planning tegen beter in - rationele planning opnieuw bezocht: een Popperiaans perspectief

19 April 2012

PhD ceremony: Mr. T. van der Meulen, 14.30 uur, Academiegebouw, Broerstraat 5, Groningen

Dissertation: Planning tegen beter in - rationele planning opnieuw bezocht: een Popperiaans perspectief

Promotor(s): prof. E.J.M.M. Arts, prof. T.A.F. Kuipers, prof. G. de Roo

Faculty: Spatial Sciences

This thesis is a meta-analysis of analyses regarding the implementation gap in spatial planning. Here two approaches can be detected. Firstly, starting from the actor who considers alternative strategies with their various effects, and secondly, starting from the context of planning routines where an intervention is regarded as a representation of shared insights in well-described circumstances. This dilemma can be related to Popper’s distinction between context of justification and context of discovery. In the former the argumentative language function is predominant, in the latter it is the descriptive language function. Rorty relates both perspectives to each other by the concept of irony. In planning practice, both perspectives clash when utilitarian-inspired proposals appear to have little support. This illustrates the relevance of the tension between ‘making’ and ‘planning subjects being together’ in policy analysis. Not every plan is implemented. This is not by definition a problem, but rather just a thing to judge with some irony. Amongst other cases this is illustrated by a description of the planning vicissitudes in the East Groningen village of Ganzedijk, which should have become an example of a new strategy for dealing with shrinking populations (but was never implemented due to several misunderstandings).

Last modified:13 March 2020 12.59 a.m.
printView this page in: Nederlands

More news

  • 02 December 2021

    Carrièreperspectief in Groningen vaak nog onbekend bij studenten

    Het aantal studenten van buiten de regio Noord-Nederland dat aan de Rijksuniversiteit Groningen (RUG) en de Hanzehogeschool Groningen gaat studeren is twee jaar na de studie ongeveer even groot als het deel van de studenten dat weer uit de regio...

  • 22 November 2021

    Growing is so much more than height and weight

    To give good advice at child health care centres and to make effective health policies children’s opportunities need to be taken into account. Not just their height and weight measurements, but also their socio-economic status including financial...

  • 02 November 2021

    Home or away: what makes 'stayers' stay?

    PhD student Jonne Thomassen has moved to a different town or city several times, as have many of her peers. Yet some people stay living close to family or friends all their lives. Thomassen is researching why some people do not move away. Family...