Measuring the costs of chapter 11 cases: professional fees in american corporate bankruptcy cases
PhD ceremony: Mr. S.J. Lubben, 16.15 uur, Academiegebouw, Broerstraat 5, Groningen
Thesis: Measuring the costs of chapter 11 cases: professional fees in american corporate bankruptcy cases
Promotor(s): prof. O. Couwenberg
Faculty: Law
In his study Stephen Lubben examined both the very large chapter 11 cases that are the subject of much academic and popular attention, and the more typical chapter 11 cases that are numerically more common. In the United States, chapter 11 continues to attract a good deal of attention, as large debtors like Lehman Brothers, General Motors, and Washington Mutual pay millions of dollars - in Lehman, perhaps as much as $1 billion - to work their way through bankruptcy. The sheer numbers involved, stacked against the losses suffered, often lead to heated claims that professionals do little in chapter 11 but loot the estate. But these impressionist endeavors provide little actual understanding of how much chapter 11 costs. And how much chapter 11 costs is important both internationally and domestically as policymakers increasingly struggle to develop tools that will mitigate the e6ects of financial distress. In his Lubben presents three broad categories of models: models of the total cost of chapter 11, models of attorney costs, and models of financial advisor costs. With these new tools it becomes possible to examine past and future chapter 11 costs, and compare those costs with other possible solutions.
Lubben’s conclusion is that time spent in chapter 11 has no relationship with cost once a fully specified model is considered. References to a professional’s “burn rate” are thus misleading, inasmuch as it implies a fixed or constant cost to chapter 11. Costs ebb and flow through the course of the case. Prepackaged chapter 11 cases are not significantly cheaper than regular chapter 11 cases. Cases filed in New York or Delaware do not cost more - in fact, these jurisdictions seem to actually reduce chapter 11 costs, likely because of their greater experience with complex chapter 11 cases. Fee examiners do not reduce the costs of big chapter 11 cases.
Complexity and the compensation structure of the professionals retained, which may itself reflect further aspects of complexity, are the key determinants of cost. Debtor size is but a loose proxy for these factors, but is itself of reduced relevance once a fuller model is developed. Complexity is associated with economies of scale, resulting in lower chapter 11 costs for the very largest, most complex cases.
Lubben concludes with the hope that his study will be but the beginning of a more subtle, less combative examination of chapter 11. Given the current economic reality, the debate is of special import.
Last modified: | 13 March 2020 01.13 a.m. |
More news
-
16 June 2025
AIWitness Project nominated for Computable Awards 2025
The AIWitness project has been nominated for the Computable Awards 2025 in the ‘Partner Project’ category. Laura Peters, Associate Professor at our faculty, is the initiator from the University of Groningen for this innovative collaboration between...
-
15 June 2025
Adriaan Wierenga, LL.M., appointed member of TOOI Advisory Committee and disciplinary judge for KNVB
Adriaan Wierenga (LL.M.), emergency law specialist and researcher at our faculty, has been appointed for a four-year term to the Advisory Committee for the Public Order Intelligence Team (TOOI) of the East Netherlands police unit by institutional...
-
12 June 2025
AI and law in dialogue: New pathways for interdisciplinary research
On Wednesday 5 June, the workshop ‘Making Connections: AI x LAW’ took place at the House of Connections, organized b yPepijn Tukker and Tim van Zuijlen (FRG) and Zoé Christoff (FSE). During the afternoon, researchers from the Faculty of Law and the...