Skip to ContentSkip to Navigation
Part of University of Groningen
Science LinXScience Linx News

Failed experiment ends up in Nature

07 January 2016

Three trips to Greenland resulted only in disappointment for climate researcher Harro Meijer from the University of Groningen Centre for Isotope Research. A few years later, however, the data from this failed field experiment on the ice cap suddenly proved extremely useful, and Meijer ended up contributing to a study that was published in Nature Climate Change on 4 January.

Gerko van der Wel (left) and Harro Meijer with a snow cannon | Photo Urban Andersson, Aftonbladet
Gerko van der Wel (left) and Harro Meijer with a snow cannon | Photo Urban Andersson, Aftonbladet

In 2005, Harro Meijer deposited a thin layer of artificial snow on the ice cap in Greenland. He returned in the subsequent two years to observe the layer as it gradually disappeared beneath a layer of snow. The reason for this research is explained here . When Meijer returned in 2006 and 2007, he found that the thaw had reached the ice cap, causing his experiment quite literally to melt away. This made it impossible to interpret the results.

‘In hindsight it was stupid’, Meijer says now. ‘One aim of our research was to record climate change. We chose a test area where our colleagues from Utrecht University had been working for years and where it always froze, but the climate change that we were actually trying to record meant that it now thawed there in the summer too.’

The spot where he worked was at an altitude of 1800 metres, which was relatively low. Meijer therefore moved to a location where the ice cap was three kilometres thick and where it did freeze all year round. He was able to conduct the experiment there instead. The data that he had collected in his first attempt was consigned to the back of a drawer, apparently useless.

That is where it would have stayed, if the melt in Greenland had not steadily reached higher areas. In 2012, the temperature on the entire ice cap rose above zero for a few days. This was unprecedented, and scientists began to wonder about the effect of all the resultant melt water.

Ice lenses (blue) in the upper 20 metres of the firn layer | Illustration from Nature Climate Change
Ice lenses (blue) in the upper 20 metres of the firn layer | Illustration from Nature Climate Change

‘The upper 50 to 80 metres of the ice cap is made up of firn, old snow with an open structure. This can absorb melt water like a sponge’, Meijer explains. The question was whether this firn layer could also cope with huge amounts of water. An international team drilled into the ice cap to find out what exactly happened to the water.

‘They needed data for comparison’, says Meijer. ‘And one of the researchers, Dirk van As, knew that I had collected core samples from the upper three metres at an altitude of 1800 metres in 2006 and 2007.’ This was thus in the years immediately preceding the thaw in Greenland.

Water that seeps down into the ‘sponge’ of the firn refreezes there. The researchers discovered that large amounts of melt water form ‘ice lenses’, slabs of ice in the firn, sometimes kilometres in length, that block the flow of water. New melt water can no longer seep down, but instead flows down from the ice cap and over the ice. The amount of melt water flowing from the ice cap into the sea consequently increases. These are the findings presented in the Nature Climate Change article.

The large slabs of ice mainly form in the lower parts of the ice cap, such as the spot where Meijer conducted his failed experiment. ‘Our data served as a kind of historical check, and showed that in 2006 and 2007 some melt water had frozen in the firn, but this was in separate chunks. It is only in the last few years that the large slabs of ice have formed.’

This is how seemingly useless data found its way into a Nature publication. ‘It was pure coincidence that Van As knew me and knew about the experiment’, says Meijer. 'Databases have been established containing the results of fieldwork, including unpublished data as well. In the Netherlands, this goes by the name of the Netherlands Polar Data Centre .’ Perhaps ‘useless’ data will regularly prove useful in the future.

Read more about the research here .

Back to Science LinX news

Last modified:21 December 2018 11.11 a.m.

More news

  • 02 April 2019

    ‘Sense of loss drives voting behaviour’

    ‘Everybody here loves that academia has returned to Friesland. We teach, carry out research and think along about solutions to problems that are relevant for Friesland,’ says Caspar van den Berg, Professor of Global and Local Governance at the UG Campus...

  • 29 March 2019

    Royal Decoration for Prof. Jeff De Hosson

    On Friday 29 March, Prof. J.Th.M. De Hosson has been awarded the Royal Decoration of Knight of the Order of the Dutch Lion. He was presented with this decoration by acting Mayor Koos Wiersma of the Westerkwartier municipality directly after his valedictory...

  • 27 March 2019

    Local levies for home owners rise by 2.7%

    Households that own their own homes will on average pay 2.7% more in municipal, provincial and water board taxes. Municipal taxes are set to rise by 3.5% on average, the water rates by 2.3% and the provincial taxes by 0.3%. This is revealed by the Atlas...