Deliver to the plan or to actual use: why construction hubs should decide material flow by material flow.
A construction logistics hub stores, prepares and combines materials off-site before they go to the building site, which can reduce congestion on site. It also creates a decision: when to release each material to the site. Sites have little room for storage, and crews can only work when their materials are there. Activities regularly start late or take longer than planned, so a delivery timed to the schedule can arrive well before it is needed and take up scarce space.
The EaSiCon project develops a digital twin that gives a real-time virtual representation of construction processes and their connected supply chains, supporting tactical and operational planning to improve efficiency and sustainability. This article presents research into material release from a construction hub, which examines when deliveries should follow the construction schedule and when they should follow actual material use on site. The two approaches were compared in a simulation of a stylised eleven-floor apartment building, planned floor by floor after an industry example. Both faced identical delays and daily variation in material use.
Two ways to release material
In schedule-driven replenishment, materials are prepared as day packages: the quantity for one activity on its expected day, bundled, labelled and delivered in advance. When progress changes, later packages can move, but those close to execution are frozen.
Kanban-based replenishment starts from the site. Material is kept in standard bins, and a bin emptied by the work signals the hub to send a replacement with the next morning's delivery. The trigger is material actually used, not a planned date.
Delays become a storage problem
When a project runs to plan, both approaches need similar storage space. As more activities are delayed, day packages build up on site because they arrive ahead of work that has moved, and peak storage climbs steeply. Under Kanban it stays at a much lower level.
Shortages have a different cause. Day packages are based on average planned use, so on a busy day a package can fall short even when nothing is delayed. A larger safety margin reduces these shortages but adds to storage. Kanban avoids shortages in all the main scenarios, at a price: slightly more deliveries once delays occur, and more material left over in part-used bins.
When storage runs out, the plan stops working
The picture sharpens when storage limits are enforced rather than only measured. Deliveries that do not fit are then held back and retried the next day. With generous or moderate limits, schedule-driven replenishment still holds up. With tight limits it breaks down, because material that cannot get onto the site cannot be used. Kanban is practically unaffected at every limit tested, since its on-site stock stays below them.
Not every material behaves the same
Storage pressure concentrates in a few flows. Cellular concrete blocks for internal walls are the largest driver: the highest volume, used again on every floor, so the same timing mismatch recurs floor by floor and accumulates across the project. Kitchens are few but bulky, taking up much storage while causing almost no shortages.
Kanban bins that are too lean create shortages, and very high daily variation in use affects Kanban too, though far less than day packages. Delivering day packages on the morning of use rather than the day before lowers storage without adding shortages. A second, less regular building schedule showed the same overall trade-off.
Conclusion and recommendations
Neither approach is best on every measure, so one rule for a whole project falls short. A hub should serve as a control point as well as a consolidation point, with different release logic for different materials. Practitioners can put this into practice through:
-
consumption-driven bins for repeated, high-volume or storage-sensitive materials
-
day packages for predictable flows that benefit from advance preparation and consolidated delivery
-
treating site storage as a limit that can block deliveries, not only as a figure to monitor
-
bins large enough to cover material use until the replacement arrives
The comparison covers logistics performance rather than cost, and assumes the hub can respond by the next morning. The next steps are to add costs, test mixed strategies per material, and calibrate the model with real delivery records, material quantities and site progress updates. A construction digital twin is designed to bring such data together, so that the release decision can follow the project as it unfolds.
For more information, please contact:
Ragnar Klabbers
Ivo Agricola
Kees Jan Roodbergen
Michael Dienstknecht
Jeroen Laarman
